engineer

tim   .

                                                      


newpad.gif (50 bytes)

.   hunkin

                                                         


cartoonist

 

MAKING DEAD OR BAD

I’ve wanted to make an arcade machine about climate change for many years. While net zero goal is admirable in principle, the details involve much madness. The other starting point for Dead or Bad was my fascination with electricity, particularly large amounts of electricity. I love substations. All the Sci-Fi shapes of the insulators, the loud hum and occasional crackle. From this technological perspective, I’ve felt for some time that the transition from fossil fuels to green electricity will be much more expensive and take much longer than environmentalists either realise or admit. There’s a limit to how much people, particularly poorer people, can afford to spend on their electricity

My initial drawings were far too complicated and confused so I abandoned the whole idea for a couple of years. It remained in the back of my mind until I thought of a way of drastically simplifying everything.

.

So this was the drawing I started from, in the midst of the lovely pylons, insulators and electrical equipment is granny in her living room. I rarely do many drawings at this early stage, I learn more from working with physical prototypes. I think better on my feet in my workshop, working with my hands. Also my tools and stores act as a giant memory map. So in this case I started with the crank handle and the generator (a large old DC motor). I wanted to see if I could make the handle harder to turn by reducing the resistance across the generator (hence increasing the current and load). This worked almost first time, 12ohms easy to turn, 2ohms very hard - all very satisfying. I also found the brightness of LEDs wired across the generator varied with speed. With LEDs as the elements of granny’s fire, it would show clearly that turning the handle was keeping Granny warm.

This got quite nerdy. I had to find a way of clipping the voltage to the LEDs to avoid blowing them up. I had a vague memory that zenner diodes can do that, but it took me several days to get a circuit working properly. Generally I find working with electronics frustrating. When a circuit doesn’t work there are usually no clues because the components workings are completely hidden inside. So I stick to simple circuits, particularly useful are ones to connect different devices together. I also always buy at least 5 of every component to swap them when a circuit doesn’t work.

Anyway, encouraged by these initial prototypes, I committed to making the whole machine. I often start with full size wood prototypes, useful for many things but particularly the ergonomics. Things like finding the comfortable height for the handle – and how to make it possible for small kids be able to see granny well enough (solved by the extreme perspective sloping the floor down steeply).

I enjoy playing with perspective, so it was fun making a 3D prototype of granny and her chair out of bits of PU foam stuck together with hot glue. To work out how to make granny inch closer to her fire as the weather worsens, I used cardboard cutouts with drawing pin hinges. It became obvious that I could do it very simply with a single pivot above her knees.

I then spent a few weeks carving granny and chair and getting the leaning forward mechanism to work. By far the most difficult thing was getting her feet to tuck under the chair as she leant forward. Not obviously difficult but its often like that. - one small detail that refuses to work. I also made Granny’s fire, using fragile chinese LED strips encased in ceramic. I broke quite a few before working out a secure way of mounting them. But the finished effect was perfect – it looked just like a real bar fire and its brightness changed so sensitively with the speed of turning the handle.

 

 

 

-Of course all the time I’m working on details like this, I’m also having more ideas for other parts of the machine. In this case, I decided my original idea of just pushing a button to insert fossil fuel was no good. Turning the handle, physical effort, was to me symbolic of green energy. I needed an equivalent for fossil fuel. So I ordered a petrol pump handle on Ebay. When it arrived, it was even better than I expected and knew it had to be part of the machine. 

To make the most of the petrol pump, I wanted it to magically pop out when granny is shivering and getting dangerously cold. This would have been tricky to do with electric actuators, but simple with pneumatic rams. One small ram opens the pump door and the other big one pushes the pump out. The great advantage of pneumatics is that both the force (by the air pressure) and the speed (via speed regulator on the cylinder ports) can be so simply and accurately set.

 

With the delayed appearance of the petrol pump, I realised that initially the machine should look ‘green’ without my beloved pylons and electrical gear. I tried to copy eco-cafe design a bit, using recycled OSB board for the casing with bright green plastic trim. The stainless steel details (the dials and frame round granny’s scene) still looked out of place so I replaced them with rusty looking Corten steel. I’d not used Corten before and found when I ground or cut it, the edges looked shiny new. Fortunately I then found that cutting it with a plasma cutter heats the steel up enough to oxidise the edges and make them blend in. In one experiment, I tried cutting the lettering for heading with my hand held plasma torch. I liked the look so went on to try back lighting it. This looked more gothic horror than green, but still it somehow finished off the machine’s appearance perfectly.

Adding the weather videos and sounds was great fun, it really brought the machine to life and gave the timeline for the whole game. The final stage as always was programming the PLC computer. So while the weather gets worse and granny inches towards her fire, turning the handle gets harder and harder. Initially I thought that when she’s shivering and the petrol pump springs out, either you pull the trigger or keep struggling to turn the handle. So either you end up BAD for resorting to fossil fuels or granny ends up DEAD. But I changed my mind and added a third possible ending if you continue to turn the handle fast enough putting in more effort. It is then possible to end up with granny warm and your green credentials intact.

 

Once on the pier it was pretty reliable. I still wanted to try adjusting the hardness of turning the handle so I added counters to the PLC program to record the numbers of people reaching the three endings. Initially it was about 75% bad, 25% dead and none green. Even after making it much easier to turn the handle though, the numbers remained roughly the same! I guess because its fun seeing the petrol pump spring out so just too irresistible to pull the trigger.

 

 

home

search

about the site

site
map

links to
other sites

where to see stuff

contact me